The Eternal Question

How many times do we see it? In it's various forms, with varied reactions to the answer.

Q: What's a good bike for a beginner?
A: The best way to start is on something smaller, lighter, more forgiving, and inspiring of confidence.

Q: I've heard that starting on a smaller bike is the best way to go but I really like the (insert totally inappropriate first bike). I have (insert various assorted reasons) that make me different than anyone else. Will I be OK?
A: I have no idea! Maybe, maybe not. But the best way to start is on something smaller, lighter, more forgiving, and inspiring of confidence. Something that will allow you to easily learn the things you need to learn to ride safely. Get too much bike and you'll certainly have more problems to deal with along the way. Sure, many have started on bikes we wouldn't recommend and grown into perfectly capable riders. Many others have not.

Allow me to make a not quite good analogy...

Q: What's the best way to grow up?
A: In a good home with loving supportive parents that help you learn the things you need to learn for later in life.

Q: I've got an abusive alcoholic for a father and a neglectful mother. Will I be OK?
A: I have no idea! Maybe, maybe not. You're certainly not growing up in the best situation. You'll certainly have more problems to deal with along the way than if you were in the best situation. Sure, many have coped with your situation and grown up to be perfectly well adjusted, functional adults. Many others have not.

Why did I say it was a not quite good analogy?

BECAUSE WITH A BIKE YOU HAVE A CHOICE!

So I ask... Which way would you like to grow up?